The New York Mets’ recent acquisition of right-handed pitcher Frankie Montas has been overshadowed by an all-too-familiar injury setback. Montas, who signed a two-year, $34 million contract with the Mets in December 2024, is sidelined due to a high-grade lat strain, requiring 6-8 weeks of recovery and further buildup. This development has raised concerns among Mets fans and management, as it mirrors the challenges the team has faced with recent free-agent signings.
Frankie Montas’s Injury
Montas’s injury occurred during spring training, shortly after he reported to camp. The discomfort in his lat muscle was significant enough to halt his throwing program, leading to the diagnosis of a high-grade strain. This setback is particularly frustrating for Montas, who had previously dealt with shoulder issues that limited his 2023 season. Despite these challenges, he managed to start 30 games for the Cincinnati Reds and Milwaukee Brewers, showcasing his resilience and determination.
Impact on the Mets’ Rotation
Montas’s absence has forced the Mets to adjust their pitching rotation plans. Initially, the team intended to implement a six-man rotation to provide additional rest and manage workloads effectively. With Montas sidelined, manager Carlos Mendoza has shifted to a five-man rotation for at least the first three weeks of the season. Key pitchers in this adjusted rotation include Clay Holmes, Sean Manaea, David Peterson, and Kodai Senga. The fifth spot will rotate among Paul Blackburn, Griffin Canning, and Tylor Megill, with Megill likely being the odd man out.
Historical Context: Injuries to Recent Free Agents
Montas’s injury is not an isolated incident for the Mets concerning recent free-agent acquisitions. In 2023, the team signed pitcher José Quintana to a two-year deal, but he was sidelined for a significant portion of the season due to a rib injury. Similarly, in 2022, the Mets signed pitcher Max Scherzer to a three-year contract, but he faced multiple injuries during his tenure, including a strained oblique and a strained side muscle. These recurring injury issues with free-agent signings have raised questions about the team’s medical assessments and the durability of players acquired through free agency.
Team’s Response and Future Considerations
In response to Montas’s injury, the Mets are exploring various options to strengthen their rotation. One potential move is re-signing José Quintana, who is currently a free agent. Quintana had an impressive performance last year and could provide the Mets with a reliable option in the rotation without depleting the team’s prospects. This strategy would be cost-effective and could help stabilize the pitching staff during Montas’s recovery period.
Additionally, the Mets are considering internal options, including Paul Blackburn and Tylor Megill, to fill the void left by Montas. Blackburn, who endured significant physical challenges due to a cerebrospinal fluid leak, is making a comeback and is in contention for a spot in the rotation. Megill, known for his versatility, could also be utilized to provide depth during this challenging period.
Conclusion
Frankie Montas’s injury has once again highlighted the challenges the New York Mets face with free-agent acquisitions and player durability. As the team navigates this setback, it will be crucial to monitor the health and performance of both internal and external options to ensure the pitching rotation remains competitive throughout the season. The Mets’ ability to adapt and respond to these challenges will be a testament to their resilience and commitment to success
