It’s possible that the Houston Astros already have a backup plan.
The Astros have shown interest in veteran infielder Jorge Polanco as a backup in case Alex Bregman departs, according to a report published Monday by Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic. According to Rosenthal, Houston is still working to resign Bregman and is also in communication with another free agent, Willy Adames. Houston is rumored to have Polanco as a backup in case they pass up those players.
The 31-year-old switch-hitter Polanco was selected to the 2019 AL All-Star team by the Minnesota Twins. He hit 33 home runs in 2021 while playing for Minnesota, and he hit 16 home runs and 45 RBIs in 118 games with the Seattle Mariners last season, while having a career-low batting average of.213. Although he has made a few career starts at third base, his primary position is middle infield, but he has moved from shortstop to second base as his career has developed.
Given what we have learned about Bregman’s salary expectations, the Astros may find it challenging to hold onto Scott Boras’ client, the two-time All-Star and Gold Glove third baseman. No one in Houston will be thrilled if Polanco is selected in free agency rather than Bregman or Adames. But for the Astros, it might be the most economical move at third base.
The Houston Astros have long been a franchise built on strategic planning and shrewd roster management, and their latest move seems to exemplify that philosophy. As the offseason gains momentum, reports suggest the Astros are exploring options for a potential replacement for Alex Bregman, with particular interest in a former All-Star player. This development raises questions about the team’s future direction and what it means for Bregman’s tenure in Houston.
Alex Bregman’s Current Status
Alex Bregman has been a cornerstone of the Astros’ success over the years. Drafted as the second overall pick in the 2015 MLB Draft, he quickly established himself as a premier third baseman in the league. Known for his exceptional defense, keen batting eye, and leadership on and off the field, Bregman has been instrumental in the Astros’ postseason runs, including their 2017 and 2022 World Series victories.
However, with his contract set to expire after the 2024 season, Bregman’s future with the team has come into question. While the Astros have expressed a desire to keep their core players intact, financial constraints and Bregman’s potential value on the open market could make retaining him challenging.
Astros’ Interest in a Former All-Star
The report linking the Astros to a former All-Star as a potential Bregman replacement suggests the team is preparing for all scenarios. While specific names haven’t been officially confirmed, speculation includes players such as Matt Chapman, a free agent known for his elite defensive skills at third base, and Josh Donaldson, a veteran who could bring a wealth of experience to the clubhouse.
Chapman, in particular, stands out as an attractive option. The 30-year-old boasts three Gold Gloves, a Platinum Glove, and a reputation as one of the best defensive third basemen in the game. Offensively, he provides power, though his batting average has been inconsistent in recent seasons.
Donaldson, though older at 38, offers a different kind of value. With an MVP award and multiple All-Star appearances to his name, he has the pedigree and leadership qualities that could help bridge the gap if the Astros transition to a new core.
Strategic Implications for the Astros
The Astros’ potential move signals a broader strategy to remain competitive in the American League West. With teams like the Texas Rangers and Seattle Mariners improving rapidly, Houston cannot afford to rest on its laurels. While replacing Bregman with a former All-Star may not offer the same long-term security, it could provide a stopgap solution or even allow the team to allocate resources to other areas, such as pitching depth or outfield reinforcements.
If the Astros do part ways with Bregman, it could signify a shift toward greater financial flexibility. The team already faces significant commitments to players like José Altuve, Yordan Alvarez, and Kyle Tucker, and extending all their stars may not be feasible under the luxury tax threshold.
The Case for Retaining Bregman
Despite the rumors, many argue that keeping Bregman should remain a priority for the Astros. At 30, he is still in his prime and has proven to be a consistent performer on the biggest stages. Bregman’s ability to get on base, combined with his power and defensive prowess, makes him a unique talent. His leadership and connection with the fan base also add intangible value.
The challenge lies in balancing these factors against the team’s broader financial picture. Bregman is likely to command a significant contract extension, potentially exceeding $200 million over eight years. Such a deal would require the Astros to make tough decisions about their roster construction.
Potential Trade Scenarios
If the Astros believe they cannot extend Bregman, they could explore trading him before the 2024 trade deadline. A midseason trade would allow Houston to recoup value in the form of prospects or major league-ready talent, rather than losing Bregman for nothing in free agency.
Teams in need of a third baseman, such as the New York Yankees, Los Angeles Dodgers, or San Diego Padres, could emerge as suitors. Bregman’s ability to contribute immediately to a contending team would make him a coveted asset.
Fan Reactions and Legacy Considerations
The idea of parting ways with Bregman has elicited mixed reactions from fans. Many view him as a face of the franchise and a player synonymous with the Astros’ golden era. Losing him could create a void not only on the field but also in the team’s identity.
However, Astros fans have witnessed the front office make tough decisions before, such as letting George Springer and Carlos Correa leave in free agency. In both cases, the team managed to stay competitive, thanks to its strong farm system and savvy acquisitions.
What Lies Ahead?
The coming months will be pivotal for the Astros as they navigate the Alex Bregman dilemma. Negotiations for an extension could provide clarity, though it remains to be seen whether the two sides can agree on terms. In the meantime, the front office’s reported interest in a former All-Star underscores its commitment to maintaining a competitive edge.
Should the Astros decide to move on from Bregman, it will mark the end of an era but also open the door to new opportunities. The next steps taken by general manager Dana Brown and owner Jim Crane will shape the franchise’s trajectory for years to come.
Conclusion
The Astros’ exploration of potential replacements for Alex Bregman is both a testament to their forward-thinking approach and a sobering reminder of the business side of baseball. While fans may hope to see Bregman remain in Houston for the long haul, the team’s interest in a former All-Star suggests they are preparing for all possibilities.
Whether through extension, trade, or free agency, the resolution of the Bregman situation will have a profound impact on the Astros’ future. For now, the speculation continues, and fans will watch closely as the offseason unfolds, hoping for clarity on one of the team’s most pivotal decisions.
