๐ง๐ฅ๐จ๐ ๐ข๐ฅ ๐๐๐๐ฆ๐: Justin Fields should be the Steelersโ starting Quarterback in 2025.TRUE OR FALSE: Justin Fields Should Be the Steelersโ Starting Quarterback in 2025?
The Pittsburgh Steelers enter the 2025 season with major questions at quarterback. Kenny Pickett has yet to prove heโs the long-term answer, and veteran Mason Rudolph is a serviceable option but not a franchise-changing player. With rumors swirling about a potential move for Justin Fields, the question arises: Should Fields be the Steelersโ starting quarterback in 2025?
Letโs break it down from both sides before making a verdict.
The Case for True: Fields Should Be the Starter
1. He Offers an Immediate Upgrade Over Pickett and Rudolph
Fields is more physically gifted than either Pickett or Rudolph. His arm strength, mobility, and playmaking ability provide a higher ceiling than what the Steelers have had in recent years. If Pittsburgh wants to compete in a division featuring Joe Burrow, Lamar Jackson, and Deshaun Watson, they need a dynamic quarterback.
2. The Steelersโ Offense Needs a Dual-Threat QB
Pittsburghโs offensive line has been inconsistent, and their run game has been up and down. Fieldsโ ability to extend plays and scramble could add another dimension to the offense, much like Lamar Jackson has done for Baltimore. A quarterback who can escape pressure and create on his own could be the missing piece.
3. Fields Has Untapped Potential
Despite an up-and-down tenure with the Chicago Bears, Fields has shown flashes of brilliance. With the right coaching and supporting cast, he could thrive in a new environment. Pittsburgh has a strong culture and better weapons, including George Pickens, Diontae Johnson, and Pat Freiermuth.
The Case for False: Fields Is Not the Answer
1. His Passing Development Is Still a Concern
Fields has struggled with consistency as a passer, particularly in reading defenses and making quick decisions. The Steelers have always valued quarterbacks who can operate efficiently in a structured offense. Fieldsโ weaknesses in these areas could make him a poor fit for what Pittsburgh wants to do.
2. Turnover and Injury Issues
Fields has a history of turnovers and has taken a lot of sacks throughout his career. Additionally, his playing style puts him at risk for injuries. Pittsburgh needs stability at the position, not another quarterback with durability concerns.
3. The Steelers Might Prefer Drafting or Sticking with Pickett
If the Steelers donโt believe Fields is a true franchise quarterback, they may prefer to stick with Pickett or pursue a long-term option in the 2025 NFL Draft. Fields might be an upgrade over Pickett now, but is he the answer for the next decade?
Final Verdict: True (But With Caution)
If the Steelers can acquire Justin Fields at a reasonable price, he should absolutely be their starter in 2025. He provides an upside that neither Pickett nor Rudolph can match, and his dual-threat ability could elevate Pittsburghโs offense. However, his passing inconsistencies and durability concerns mean the Steelers should still keep their options open for the future.
What do you think? Should Pittsburgh take a chance on Fields, or should they look elsewhere for their next franchise quarterback?
